NFL Defensive Player of the Year Odds

The NFL season still has its defensive storyline unwritten, but the top of the board already tells you where the smart money leans. Will Anderson sits at +120 at DraftKings, good for 45.5% implied, with Dallas Turner at +400 and Jeffery Simmons at +750 chasing close behind. I pull this from 74 players priced across bet365, BetMGM, DraftKings, Caesars, FanDuel, 5 sportsbooks in all, with the board refreshed as of November 17, 2026.

The spread from the top names down to the field is where the real work happens. Down near the bottom, Zach Allen sits at +50000, a price that only cashes if the stat sheet gets strange in a hurry. That gap between the favorites and the rest is exactly why shopping the number across books matters before you lock anything in.

2026 NFL Defensive Player of the Year Odds

Updated Tuesday, November 17 · best price across 5 booksbet365BetMGMDraftKingsCaesarsFanDuel
Favorite#1
Will AndersonDE · Texans
+12045.5% implied · DraftKings
7d -29%open -74%
Second favorite#2
Dallas TurnerLB · Vikings
+40020.0% implied · FanDuel
7d -60%open -93%
Third favorite#3
Jeffery SimmonsDT · Bears
+75011.8% implied · bet365
7d -7%open -93%
Movers this weekChristian Gonzalez+9000 → +27500+206%Milton Williams+10000 → +30000+200%Sauce Gardner+15000 → +40000+167%Kamari Lassiter+11250 → +30000+167%
#PlayerBest priceBookImplied7 daysSince start
1Will AndersonDE · Texans+120DraftKings45.5%-29%-74%
2Dallas TurnerLB · Vikings+400FanDuel20.0%-60%-93%
3Jeffery SimmonsDT · Bears+750bet36511.8%-7%-93%
4Fred WarnerLB · 49ers+800BetMGM11.1%+36%-70%
5Greg RousseauLB · Bills+2000BetMGM4.8%+54%-50%
6T.J. WattLB · Steelers+3000BetMGM3.2%+79%+150%
7Andrew Van GinkelLB · Vikings+3000BetMGM3.2%-37%-78%
8Dexter LawrenceDT · Bengals+3300Caesars2.9%even+88%
9Kyle HamiltonS · Ravens+6600BetMGM1.5%+9%+9%
10Nik BonittoLB · Broncos+8000BetMGM1.2%+25%+456%
11Byron YoungLB · Rams+10000BetMGM1.0%––
12Chase YoungDE · Saints+10000BetMGM1.0%+50%-44%
Show all 74 playersShow fewer
13Devon WitherspoonCB · Seahawks+10000BetMGM1.0%+33%+75%
14Maxx CrosbyDE · Raiders+10000BetMGM1.0%+150%+600%
15Abdul CarterLB · Giants+10000BetMGM1.0%+67%+133%
16Travon WalkerDE · Jaguars+10000bet3651.0%even–
17Quinyon MitchellCB · Eagles+10000bet3651.0%even+122%
18Byron MurphyDT · Seahawks+15000Caesars0.7%+50%-25%
19Danielle HunterDE · Texans+15000BetMGM0.7%+100%+450%
20Arvell ReeseLB · Giants+15000FanDuel0.7%––
21Montez SweatDE · Bears+15000BetMGM0.7%even-20%
22Nick EmmanworiS · Seahawks+15000BetMGM0.7%+88%+95%
23Myles GarrettDE · Rams+15000Caesars0.7%+25%+122%
24Aaron DonaldDT · Rams+15000BetMGM0.7%eveneven
25Leonard WilliamsDT · Seahawks+15000bet3650.7%+50%even
26Boye MafeDE · Bengals+15000bet3650.7%+20%+20%
27Jessie BatesS · Jaguars+15000bet3650.7%––
28Antoine WinfieldS · Buccaneers+15000bet3650.7%––
29Nick BosaDE · 49ers+20000bet3650.5%+33%+789%
30Derwin JamesS · Chargers+20000bet3650.5%––
31Ed OliverDT · Bills+20000DraftKings0.5%+17%–
32Devin LloydLB · Panthers+25000BetMGM0.4%+100%+38%
33Derek StingleyCB · Texans+25000BetMGM0.4%+100%+250%
34Carson SchwesingerLB · Browns+25000BetMGM0.4%+50%+38%
35Chris JonesDT · Chiefs+25000BetMGM0.4%+100%+88%
36Talanoa HufangaS · Broncos+25000BetMGM0.4%even+50%
37George KarlaftisDE · Chiefs+25000BetMGM0.4%even+100%
38Micah ParsonsDE · Packers+25000bet3650.4%+33%+213%
39Trent McDuffieCB · Rams+25000BetMGM0.4%+50%+100%
40Josh Hines-AllenDE · Jaguars+30000FanDuel0.3%+100%+125%
41Travis HunterWR · Jaguars+30000Caesars0.3%+150%+42%
42Trey HendricksonLB · Ravens+30000Caesars0.3%+213%+800%
43Alex HighsmithLB · Steelers+30000Caesars0.3%+150%+150%
44Blake CashmanLB · Vikings+30000FanDuel0.3%––
45Jared VerseDE · Browns+40000FanDuel0.2%+100%+233%
46Pat SurtainCB · Broncos+40000FanDuel0.2%+150%+317%
47Christian GonzalezCB · Patriots+40000FanDuel0.2%+206%+400%
48Tuli TuipulotuLB · Chargers+40000bet3650.2%––
49Jalen CarterDT · Eagles+50000BetMGM0.2%+271%+793%
50Xavier McKinneyS · Packers+50000BetMGM0.2%+33%+75%
51Will McDonaldDE · Jets+50000BetMGM0.2%eveneven
52Jonathan GreenardLB · Eagles+50000BetMGM0.2%+178%–
53Roquan SmithLB · Ravens+50000BetMGM0.2%+100%+133%
54Bradley ChubbLB · Bills+50000BetMGM0.2%even-33%
55Laiatu LatuDE · Colts+50000BetMGM0.2%+155%+329%
56DeMarcus LawrenceLB · Seahawks+50000BetMGM0.2%+167%+167%
57Quinnen WilliamsDT · Cowboys+50000BetMGM0.2%+155%–
58Josh SweatLB · Cardinals+50000BetMGM0.2%eveneven
59Milton WilliamsDT · Patriots+50000BetMGM0.2%+200%+175%
60Zack BaunLB · Eagles+50000BetMGM0.2%even–
61Sauce GardnerCB · Colts+50000BetMGM0.2%+167%–
62Kamari LassiterCB · Texans+50000BetMGM0.2%+167%+200%
Only one book still prices these
63DeForest BucknerDT · 49ers+15000FanDuel0.7%––
64Ventrell MillerLB · Jaguars+15000FanDuel0.7%––
65Jevon HollandS · Giants+15000DraftKings0.7%––
66Rashan GaryLB · Cowboys+15000BetMGM0.7%––
67Kyler GordonCB · Bears+20000DraftKings0.5%––
68Amani HookerS · Bills+20000DraftKings0.5%––
69Jalen PitreS · Texans+20000DraftKings0.5%––
70Odafe OwehLB · Commanders+25000BetMGM0.4%––
71Alex SingletonLB · Broncos+25000DraftKings0.4%––
72Khalil MackLB · Chargers+25000DraftKings0.4%––
73Kevin ByardS · Patriots+25000BetMGM0.4%––
74Zach AllenDE · Broncos+50000BetMGM0.2%––

Best price is the longest number we found across bet365, BetMGM, DraftKings, Caesars, FanDuel. Implied probability strips nothing out; the whole board adds to more than 100% and that gap is the books’ margin. Movement is the change in what a winning dollar pays, so a move means the same thing at the top of the board and at the bottom; green means the price shortened. It reads across the books quoting a player both then and now, and a row too thinly quoted to compare shows a dash rather than a number. Since start runs from the first day we have every book’s price, which is not the market’s opening line.

Sacks and Strips Beat Tape Study Every Time

This award has a long habit of going to whoever piles up sacks and forces turnovers, not whoever grades out best on film. Pass rushers own the history of this trophy for a reason. Voters gravitate toward the box score they can see, not the assignment-sound reps buried in coverage.

That bias should shape how you bet the board. A player racking up sacks and takeaways, even on a defense that isn’t dominant overall, holds more value than a lockdown corner or a stout run defender who never shows up in the highlight column. When you’re deciding between two similarly priced names, lean toward the one piling up the countable stats. Voters reward production you can point to, and the number usually follows that same logic before the season ever settles.

Cashing In Before the Sack Totals Pile Up

The best price on this market shows up before anyone has separated from the pack. Once a player starts stacking sacks or takeaways in bunches, the number tightens fast and the value dries up. Betting early, while the field is still bunched and the box scores are thin, is where the discount lives.

That early position also sets up a hedge later. If your pick opens a gap on the field as the sack and takeaway totals roll in, the shortened price lets you trade out for guaranteed profit or lock in partial value on the other side. Wait too long and you’re buying in at a number that’s already priced for the stats everyone can see, which strips out most of the edge that made the bet worth making in the first place.

Splash Plays Swing This Number, Not Tackle Counts

Tackle totals barely move this market. What actually shifts the price is the stuff that shows up in a highlight package: sacks, forced fumbles, and interceptions. A quiet stretch without a strip-sack or a pick-six can stall a favorite’s price just as fast as a hot streak can shorten it.

Christian Gonzalez is the clearest example of that right now, having drifted by 206% to sit at +40000. That kind of swing almost always traces back to a run of splash plays or a dry spell, not a change in how a defender is playing overall. Keep an eye on box-score production week to week, since that’s the signal the number actually reacts to, far more than any analytics grade or coach’s praise.

Get Jimmy's picks for free!

You'll get free picks via email, plus access to exclusive discounts!

We won't spam you - ever. No obligation. You can unsubscribe at any time.

×

Subscribe to Jimmy Boyd's Free Picks

The best free picks delivered to your email every single day!