Jimmy Boyd in 
Every NFL season, especially after a heartbreaking loss or a controversial call, some fans start asking, “Are NFL games fixed?” The short answer is no – NFL games are not rigged.
Yet the conspiracy theory that the league scripts outcomes or that referees favor certain teams just won’t die. Why do so many believe the NFL might pull strings behind the scenes?
One reason is the emotional nature of fandom. When a questionable referee decision or a shocking comeback goes against our team, it’s easier to cry conspiracy than to accept the harsh randomness of sports.
Over the years, a series of high-profile officiating blunders and bizarre moments have poured fuel on the “NFL is rigged” fire. Social media amplifies these incidents, turning isolated bad calls into “proof” of a grand fix. Add in the rise of legal sports gambling (especially NFL betting) – with millions riding on point spreads and fantasy stats – and every odd outcome starts looking suspicious to someone.
However, extraordinary plays and controversial calls are part of the drama of real, unscripted competition. Even NFL players have openly mocked the rigging paranoia.
In early 2023, former running back Arian Foster joked on a podcast that the NFL hands out a “script” for each season – a tongue-in-cheek nod to the conspiracy theories. Current stars like Micah Parsons and Alvin Kamara ran with the gag, tweeting about the scripted twists in their careers (Kamara quipped that when he saw his season’s script, he “almost walked out of the facility”). The humor of these script memes highlights what most players and savvy fans know: the idea of the NFL being rigged is more fiction than reality.
Blown Calls and Missed Flags: Do Officials Prove a Fix?
Nothing ignites rigging accusations like a blown call by the refs. NFL officiating isn’t perfect – far from it – and critics point to mistakes as evidence of foul play.
The 2019 NFC Championship Game is a prime example. In that game, a Los Angeles Rams defender leveled New Orleans Saints receiver Tommylee Lewis well before the ball arrived – a textbook pass interference – yet no flag was thrown.
The “no-call” was so egregious that it likely cost the Saints a Super Bowl trip, sparking outrage among fans and cries that the league wanted the Rams in the big game. Under intense public pressure, the NFL admitted the refs blew the call, but they attributed it to human error, not any league mandate.
In a court filing responding to a lawsuit by angry Saints fans, NFL lawyers plainly stated that the officials “mistakenly” missed the penalty and that referees are human and make errors.
In other words, the league acknowledged the mistake – a pretty odd thing to do if they were secretly orchestrating outcomes.
From the infamous “no-call” against the Saints to the “Fail Mary” touchdown controversy of 2012 (when replacement referees botched a game-deciding call on a Hail Mary pass), blown calls have created black eyes for the NFL. But these incidents hurt the league’s credibility; they don’t help it.
Far from being swept under the rug, officiating errors often lead to rule changes or personnel shake-ups. After the Saints-Rams debacle, for instance, the NFL briefly made pass interference calls reviewable by replay – an unprecedented step to avoid such a mistake in the future. If the league was fixing games, they wouldn’t be continually tweaking rules and training to improve referee accuracy.
It’s also worth noting that officials are not exempt from accountability. They get graded on performance, and egregious errors can affect whether they receive plum assignments like playoff games or the Super Bowl.
In rare cases, officials have been demoted or even let go after high-profile mistakes. The bottom line is that NFL referees sometimes blow calls due to human fallibility, not because they’re in on a fix.
Dean Blandino, former NFL officiating chief, has openly debunked claims of rigged games. Blandino emphasizes that referees do sometimes err, but not as part of any conspiracy.
In his words, “There’s no conspiracy. … It’s the hardest sport to rig when you think about football with seven different officials”, noting that if anyone tried, keeping it secret would be nearly impossible.
He even jokes that his own brother suspects him of hiding an NFL script, which Blandino flatly denies. When the very person once in charge of NFL officiating insists there’s no fix, it’s a strong sign that the league isn’t secretly scripting outcomes.
Big-Market Teams, Star Quarterbacks, and “NFL Bias”
Another pillar of the NFL conspiracy theory is the belief that the league favors certain teams or players – typically big-market franchises or superstar QBs – to drive TV ratings.
Fans have long alleged that stars like Tom Brady get preferential treatment from refs, or that the NFL “wants” teams like the Dallas Cowboys in the playoffs because it’s good for business. Every questionable roughing-the-passer call that protects Brady, or prime-time game featuring the Cowboys, feeds the narrative for skeptics.
It’s undeniable that star players sometimes receive the benefit of the doubt – but that’s a far cry from a league-wide fix. Referees are human (there’s that theme again), and like all humans, they can be influenced by reputation and circumstances.
A borderline call might go Brady’s way one week and against a no-name rookie the next, not due to NFL orders but due to subconscious bias or simply the angle of view.
The Kansas City Chiefs have become the latest target of “rigged” cries, with some rival fans claiming the NFL is building a Chiefs dynasty. When the Chiefs won a few close playoff games with the aid of some iffy calls, social media lit up with claims of a fix. Even the Chiefs’ own owner, Clark Hunt, has heard the chatter – and he’s chuckled at the absurdity. “You almost have to laugh… there’s definitely no conspiracy, right? It’s the nature of the game. And when you start having a lot of success, people like to start making excuses for why you’re having the success,” Hunt said.
Commissioner Roger Goodell himself was asked about the “NFL helps the Chiefs” theory during his State of the League address and called it “a ridiculous theory” that referees favor any team. He did acknowledge fans’ frustrations by saying the league constantly works to improve officiating – reinforcing that the issue is referees’ competence, not conspiracy.
In fact, an analysis of penalty stats showed the Chiefs haven’t gotten more favorable calls than other teams – they’re roughly league average in how often penalties help them out. The perception of favoritism often correlates with visibility: successful teams like the Chiefs or Patriots are on national TV a lot and go deep in the playoffs, so we remember every borderline call that goes their way.
Meanwhile, we forget the ones that go against them. For example, few non-Chiefs fans recall the bad calls that hurt Kansas City in a 2016 playoff loss, because those didn’t spawn a catchy conspiracy narrative.
The NFL certainly loves its superstar storylines – who doesn’t enjoy watching legends like Brady or Mahomes in the spotlight? – but the games still have to be won on the field. If popularity alone dictated who wins, Tom Brady’s perfect 16-0 Patriots wouldn’t have been thwarted by the underdog New York Giants in Super Bowl XLII.
If the league could script things, the biggest brands would always meet in the Super Bowl (yet we’ve never seen a Cowboys vs. Patriots Super Bowl, for instance). Clearly, that’s not how it works. The league’s marketing machine will always hype big names and big markets, but come kickoff, the players decide the outcome through performance (and occasionally, yes, a bit of luck).
The “Vegas Knows” Myth: Betting Lines and Late-Game Oddities
Sports betting has given birth to its own subset of NFL fix theories. How many times have we heard someone say, “Vegas must have known something,” when a final score miraculously hits the point spread or total?
For instance, maybe a team is favored by 6 points and, in the final seconds, instead of kneeling, they kick a field goal to win by exactly 6 – causing half of the bettors to push and the others to lose by a hook.
To a frustrated gambler, that kind of uncanny spread result can feel too perfect. It’s tempting to imagine shadowy bookmakers pulling puppet strings, or the NFL orchestrating a close finish to keep games exciting.
In reality, those nail-biter betting finishes are usually just the product of two things: the NFL’s parity and the skill of linesmakers in setting the NFL odds. The league has so much competitive balance (by design) that many games naturally come down to one possession.
And sportsbooks set point spreads with uncanny accuracy, precisely because they analyze every matchup in detail. When they get it right, it might look almost scripted that a game was decided by 3 points instead of 4.
Note: Need a place to bet? Check out our sportsbook review page to see the places we recommend.
But if you think oddsmakers always nail it, remember the times the actual result blows the spread out of the water. Anyone who bet on a “sure thing” favorite that lost by 20 can attest the bookies aren’t infallible!
Crucially, the house doesn’t need games to be fixed to make money. Sportsbooks make their living on the 50/50 balance of bets and the vigorish (the cut taken from losers). A fix would actually ruin them – if someone had inside info on a rigged outcome, they’d hammer that side and the books would suffer huge losses.
That’s why bookmakers are extremely vigilant for any signs of impropriety. If an avalanche of strange bets came in on a normally obscure game, sportsbooks would raise alarms in a heartbeat. As one veteran oddsmaker noted, if they see “unnatural money” flooding in without explanation, they’ll pull the game off the board until they figure out why. It’s often an injury or a well-known sharp bettor behind a line move.
But if it ever pointed to a fix, you can bet Vegas would alert the authorities. Sportsbooks need honest games – a betting scandal could drive away customers and even bankrupt books if they end up on the wrong side. They’d be the first to blow the whistle on any attempt to fix an NFL game.
The NFL, for its part, is hyper-aware of gambling’s influence. With betting now legal and embraced via league partnerships, the NFL has beefed up monitoring and education for players and officials. Several players have been suspended in recent years for merely betting on NFL games, even without any hint of game-fixing.
The league’s policy is crystal clear: any actual or attempted game-fixing results in permanent banishment from the NFL. The NFL and its Players Association even put out a joint statement about their “unwavering commitment to protecting the integrity of the game”.
They know that if fans ever lost faith that what they’re watching is real, the entire enterprise would be in jeopardy. For a multi-billion dollar business built on competition, no storyline or ratings boost is worth the risk of a rigging scandal.
High-Profile “Rigged” Games: Separating Fact from Fiction
Let’s revisit a few famous NFL moments often cited by conspiracy-minded fans, and see why they don’t hold up as evidence of rigging:
- Super Bowl XL (2006) – The Pittsburgh Steelers beat the Seattle Seahawks, but Seahawks fans were livid about a string of questionable calls (a tight offensive pass interference that nullified a Seattle touchdown, a dubious Ben Roethlisberger TD where the ball barely broke the plane, etc.). To this day, some insist the refs “handed Pittsburgh the game.” The reality? The calls in question were bang-bang judgments that could have gone either way – hardly a smoking gun. The NFL actually admitted one mistake from that game (a low block penalty that shouldn’t have been called on Seattle), but other calls were judgment calls that, while debatable, fell within the rules. If the league had truly wanted to script a Steelers win, it’s odd that they let the game remain so close and sloppy instead of ensuring a comfortable Pittsburgh blowout. The far more likely explanation is that a few close calls all happened to favor one team – frustrating, yes; engineered, no.
- The “Tuck Rule” (2002 AFC Divisional Playoff) – No single call sparked more “rigged” cries than the infamous Tuck Rule game. In a snowy 2001 playoff, New England’s Tom Brady had the ball knocked from his hand by the Oakland Raiders – a fumble that should have sealed a Raiders win. Instead, refs invoked a little-known rule that an arm moving forward starts a passing motion, making it an incomplete pass, not a fumble. The Patriots kept the ball and eventually won in overtime, launching the Brady-Belichick dynasty. Raiders fans were apoplectic, convinced the NFL created a rule on the spot to save Brady. In truth, the tuck rule was already on the books (obscure as it was) and had been applied before. You could argue it was a bad rule (the NFL actually eliminated it years later), but it was applied correctly that night. Conspiracy theorists ask why such a bizarre rule existed – was it to help the Patriots? But the rule wasn’t invented for that game; it was a decade-old oddity in the rulebook. The call was hugely controversial, but not proof of a fix. If anything, it showed how arcane rules can impact a game in ways fans (and even players) don’t fully understand, which in turn fuels suspicion.
- 2018 AFC Championship (Patriots vs. Chiefs) – This game birthed a theory that the NFL wanted a Brady vs. Rams Super Bowl (GOAT vs. young upstart coach). Late in the 4th quarter, the Chiefs intercepted Brady, which would have sealed the game – but a flag came out for offsides on Chiefs defender Dee Ford, nullifying the pick. New England went on to win. Fans howled that the refs “bailed out” the Pats. But watch the replay: Dee Ford was clearly lined up offsides, an unforced error on his part. The official did his job by calling a foul that literally anyone watching on TV could see (Ford’s helmet was past the line of scrimmage before the snap). If the NFL were scripting outcomes, wouldn’t they prefer not to rely on such an obvious penalty? The simpler story is that a player made a costly mistake at the worst time, and it legitimately cost his team – no conspiracy required.
- Any Game Involving Tom Brady – Let’s face it, Brady’s name comes up a lot in these discussions. The man has more rings than fingers, and a segment of fans think it’s too good to be true. They’ll cite examples like referees picking up a flag after Brady complains, or suspiciously few holding calls on his offensive line. It’s true that Brady, like all greats, worked the officials and occasionally got a break. But he was also on the wrong end of some big decisions (remember Deflategate – the league actually suspended Brady four games over allegedly under-inflated footballs). If the NFL’s goal was to protect its golden boy at all costs, punishing him in a high-profile scandal is a funny way to show it. The far more plausible narrative: Brady’s teams won a lot thanks to clutch play and great coaching (with maybe a dash of minor rule-bending), and fans who couldn’t believe their dominance looked for external reasons. Sometimes, greatness doesn’t need a conspiracy.
In each of these cases, what conspiracy theorists see as part of a master plan can be explained by the mundane mix of human error, weird rules, and the breaks of the game. The NFL is indeed an entertainment business – it thrives on excitement and drama – but that drama is real.
Unlike pro wrestling (which is scripted entertainment), NFL outcomes aren’t decided in advance. Players and coaches prepare like crazy to win, and you can see the raw emotion when they succeed or fail. Think about it: if games were fixed, would we witness the genuine despair of players who fall short, or the sheer joy of underdogs who pull off miracles? Those unscripted moments are exactly what makes sports compelling.
Why the NFL Needs Games to Be Legit
It’s important to understand how much the NFL has to lose if a game-fixing scheme ever came to light. The NFL isn’t just a sport – it’s a massive business empire built on fan trust.
Billions of dollars are tied up in TV deals, sponsorships, betting partnerships, and merchandise sales, all predicated on the idea that the games are fair competitions. If that trust shattered, the NFL’s empire could collapse.
League officials know this. That’s why you’ll often hear Goodell and others talk about “protecting the integrity of the game.” The NFL has an entire security and compliance apparatus devoted to sniffing out anything that might compromise fairness – from players gambling, teams tampering with equipment, or officials who might have conflicts of interest.
The NFL Referees Association (the officials’ union) even felt compelled to publicly refute recent claims of bias toward the Chiefs, calling such allegations “insulting and preposterous.” The folks in stripes take pride in their professionalism; suggesting they’d sell out the game doesn’t sit well at all.
Remember too that pulling off a fix would require a conspiracy of many. Unlike an individual sport (say tennis or boxing) where one athlete could throw a match, an NFL game has dozens of players and coaches on each sideline, plus seven officials and replay reviewers.
For a game to be rigged convincingly, many people would likely have to be in on it – and keep quiet forever. As Dean Blandino pointed out, the NFL has too many variables to rig and keeping such a plot secret would be “nearly impossible”.
In a league where leaks about draft picks or trade rumors are commonplace, imagine trying to hide an orchestrated game outcome. Someone would talk. (Just look at how quickly any scandal – like a team illegally videotaping opponents or a player’s off-field misdeeds – makes headlines. The NFL lives in a fishbowl where secrets are hard to keep.)
Even the appearance of impropriety is something the league avoids like the plague. When a former NBA referee was caught actually fixing games for gamblers in the 2000s, it cast a cloud of suspicion on officiating in all sports. The NFL responded by increasing oversight of their own refs, including analyzing penalty trends.
If any NFL official started consistently making calls that swung point spreads suspiciously, both the league and Las Vegas would notice in an instant. In fact, Las Vegas oddsmakers track which refs work which games and compare that data with betting outcomes – if something smelled fishy with a particular ref, it would be “reported immediately to the NFL”.
The league also drills it into players and coaches that even joking about games being fixed can undermine fan confidence. That’s probably why players turned the Arian Foster “script” joke into an opportunity to laugh at the idea – they know it’s absurd and don’t want fans taking it seriously.
The NFL certainly embraces drama, but it has to be organic drama. If a team comes back from 25 points down in a Super Bowl (looking at you, Falcons vs. Patriots in Super Bowl LI), it’s because crazy things can happen in sports, not because a writer’s room penned a Hollywood ending.
The Real Reasons Crazy Things Happen on Sundays
If not a grand secret fix, what explains those eyebrow-raising NFL moments that feel almost cinematic? A few real factors:
- Parity and Competition: The NFL’s structure (salary cap, draft order, revenue sharing) is designed to keep teams on an equal footing. Even the best teams can get challenged by underdogs. As a result, we get a ton of close games and surprising upsets – which can give the illusion of some invisible hand ensuring every game is a thriller. In truth, it’s the parity at work and the sheer competitive drive of professional athletes who play to win, not to hit a Vegas spread.
- Human Error (Players and Coaches): We often forget that players and coaches can blunder in monumental ways. A boneheaded penalty (lining up offsides, roughing the passer at the wrong time) or a terrible play call can swing a game’s outcome just as much as a ref’s call. Fans might wonder, “How could he make that mistake in such a big moment?” and some will conclude he must have been “paid off.” But having played sports, we know split-second decisions can go wrong under pressure. To err is human – and that applies to everyone on the field, not just the officials.
- Confirmation Bias: When you suspect the NFL is rigged, you tend to notice everything that supports that belief and ignore what doesn’t. Did your team get a favorable call? “That was just a makeup for earlier.” Did a rival team get one? “Aha, the fix is in!” In reality, every team has benefited from a bad call at times and been burned by one at others. But conspiracy thinking remembers only the evidence that fits the theory. It’s a selective memory that can convince you something is going on, even when it’s not. (We have also covered more cognitive biases in sports betting and how to protect yourself from them.)
- Unscripted Drama: Unbelievable comebacks, controversial finishes, miracle plays – these have been part of football long before the NFL became a TV juggernaut. The “Immaculate Reception” in 1972 was so improbable that people joked it was divine intervention. The “Music City Miracle” in 2000 (Titans’ last-second lateral TD) left viewers’ jaws on the floor. These weren’t scripted by the NFL; they were delivered by the chaos of sport. The league doesn’t need to rig games when reality so often provides storylines better than any script.
Conclusion: No, the NFL Isn’t Fixed – And That’s Why We Love It
Believing the NFL is fixed would mean believing that thousands of players, coaches, and officials are all world-class actors pulling off the most elaborate sham in sports – with zero credible whistleblowers. That strains all logic.
What’s far more believable is that the NFL is exactly what it appears to be: a highly competitive, sometimes flawed, often unpredictable sports league. The intrigue and excitement come precisely because we don’t know what will happen. As fans (and bettors), we’ve all felt the sting of a crazy loss or the ecstasy of a miraculous win. Those raw emotions are real, not pre-written.
If you’re still on the fence, consider this: the NFL’s greatest asset is the trust of its audience. The league makes mountains of money as long as we believe that on any given Sunday, any team can win.
The moment fans think outcomes are preordained, the entire house of cards collapses. It’s simply not in the NFL’s interest to risk that for the sake of propping up a particular team or narrative. Past scandals (like Spygate or Bountygate) have shown that the league will punish teams that break the rules – even elite teams – precisely to reassure fans that the competition is real.
So, are NFL games fixed? In a word, no. The drama is unscripted, the agony and ecstasy genuine. The conspiracy theories will keep popping up every time a ref misses a call or a game swings in an unlikely direction. It’s human nature to seek patterns and scapegoats when things feel unjust.
But at the end of the day, the simplest explanation holds: the NFL is chaotic and captivating because it isn’t rigged. Instead of blaming imaginary puppeteers when your bet or team falls short, tip your cap to the unpredictability of sports – the very thing that keeps us watching, week after week, season after season.
Winning your bets is tough, that’s why we recommend finding one of the best NFL handicappers on our site and signing up for a package of premium NFL picks to help you beat the odds and make money this season!
