$1 for $100 in Picks – BoydsBets Deal

If you’ve ever looked at a betting line and seen something like “Total 47.5 (O/U)”, you’ve encountered a total bet.

Also known as an over/under, a total is a wager on the combined score of both teams in a game.

Instead of picking a winner or covering a point spread, you’re betting on whether the game’s total points (or runs, goals, etc.) will be over or under a number set by the sportsbook.

It’s a straightforward concept – you’re essentially rooting for either a high-scoring shootout or a low-scoring battle – but there’s plenty of nuance behind the scenes.

In this guide, we’ll break down what total bets are, how sportsbooks set those lines, and how you can approach betting overs and unders like a pro.

We’ll look at real examples across popular sports (NFL, NBA, MLB, college football, NHL, and more), explore different types of total bets (from team totals to first-half lines and prop totals), and share tips on reading line movement and finding an edge.

By the end, you’ll know the ins and outs of over/under betting – from why a football game’s total might suddenly drop due to a blizzard, to when it’s smart to grab the over before the line moves.

Let’s dive in!

What Does Over/Under (Total) Mean in Sports Betting?

A total (over/under) bet is one of the most common wagers in sports betting. The sportsbook sets a predicted total score for a game, and you choose whether the actual combined score of the two teams will go over that number or under it.

It doesn’t matter which team wins the game – all that matters is the sum of the final scores.

For example, let’s say an NFL game between the Chiefs and Bills has a total set at 48.5 points.

If you bet the over, you need the combined score of both teams to be 49 or more points for your bet to win (e.g. a 28-24 final score = 52 points, which wins the over).

If you bet the under, you need the teams to score 48 or fewer points combined (e.g. 21-17 final = 38 points, which wins the under).

The “.5” in 48.5 ensures there’s no tie; there’s either over or under. Sportsbooks often use half-point increments to avoid a push, but if a total is a whole number and the game lands exactly on that total, it’s a push (the bet is a tie and you get your money back).

For instance, if the total was 48 and the game ended 28-20 (48 points), everyone’s bets would push – no winners or losers on the total.

Just like point spreads, total bets typically come with standard odds, usually around -110 on each side (meaning you bet $110 to win $100). The odds can vary slightly (e.g. over -115 / under -105) if the book adjusts for imbalance, but the concept is the same: pick over or under the set number. It’s a simple two-way proposition: you’re either cheering for points or for defense.

In short: “Over” means you expect a high-scoring game, “Under” means you expect a low-scoring game. It’s a fun bet because you can win (or lose) regardless of which team wins the game – you’re just following the scoreboard. Now, let’s explore how those totals are determined and what affects them.

How Do Sportsbooks Set Totals?

Sportsbooks don’t pull total numbers out of a hat – they use a mix of statistics, models, and expert analysis to set a solid line. The goal for the oddsmakers is to predict a total that will attract balanced action on the over and under, while also reflecting the likely outcome of the game. Here are some key factors sportsbooks consider when setting a total:

  • Team Offenses and Defenses: First and foremost, they look at how potent each team’s offense is and how stingy each defense is. Two high-flying offensive teams (think Kansas City Chiefs-level offense) will naturally produce a higher total than two teams with struggling offenses. Conversely, if both teams have top-tier defenses or weak offenses, the projected total will be lower.
  • Recent Performance & Averages: Oddsmakers examine each team’s recent scoring output and season averages. If Team A typically scores 28 points per game and Team B scores 24, and each allows around 21 points on defense, the book might project something in that ballpark. They also factor in recent games: if a team’s last few matchups were unusually high or low scoring (maybe due to overtime or facing extreme opponents), they’ll adjust for any anomalies.
  • Head-to-Head Matchups: Some teams, when they play each other, consistently produce high or low scores due to matchup factors. For example, a certain basketball team might push the pace against a particular opponent, leading to high totals, or a football rivalry might historically be a defensive slugfest. Sportsbooks will note these trends if they’re relevant (though they’re careful not to overweight historical trends without reason).
  • Pace of Play and Style: The tempo of the game is huge. In fact, a great handicapping adage is “everything begins with pace” when betting totals – the speed at which teams play often dictates how many scoring opportunities occur . For basketball, this means possessions per game; for football, plays per game. A fast-break NBA team or a hurry-up college football offense means more chances to score (higher totals), while a grind-it-out half-court basketball team or a run-heavy football team that chews up the clock means fewer chances (lower totals). Sportsbooks analyze the styles: are the teams slow and methodical or quick and aggressive? An uptempo matchup (say, two fast-paced NBA teams) might see a total in the 230s, whereas two defensive-minded, slow-tempo teams might be in the 190s.
  • Situational and Environmental Factors: Oddsmakers account for things like weather, venue, and schedule spot. Weather is mostly a factor in outdoor sports like football and baseball: a game in heavy rain or strong wind might slash the total because those conditions can stifle offense (think of a football game in a windy snowstorm – passing and kicking become adventures, favoring the under). On the flip side, a perfect day or a dome stadium (controlled conditions) is conducive to scoring. In baseball, wind blowing out at Wrigley Field can bump a total up (more homers!), while wind blowing in can lower it. Altitude and park factors (like Coors Field in MLB leads to higher totals due to thin air) also come into play. And don’t forget scheduling: a team playing its third game in five nights in the NBA might be tired (possibly leading to lower scoring), or a short week in NFL could affect offensive preparation.
  • Injuries and Lineups: Sportsbooks keep a close eye on injury reports. If a star quarterback or an elite scorer in basketball is injured or resting, the expected points for that team drop and the total will be adjusted downward. Conversely, if a team gets a key offensive player back from injury, the offense might get a boost. Even defensive injuries matter – if a team’s best defensive player is out, the opponent might score more easily, nudging the total up. In sports like basketball, late-breaking lineup news (e.g. a star player resting) can cause books to pull a total off the board and repost at a new number.

All these ingredients (and more) go into the oddsmaker’s stew to cook up a total.

The end result might be something like “O/U 47” or “Total: 6.5 runs” or “Over/Under 5.5 goals”, depending on the sport. It’s a number that reflects the bookmaker’s best prediction of the combined score.

Of course, that number isn’t set in stone – once betting opens, the total can move (we’ll cover line movement shortly). But before we get into why totals move, let’s look at what these totals actually look like across different sports with some examples.

Totals in Different Sports (with Examples)

Every sport has its own scoring system and flow, so totals can mean very different numbers depending on what you’re betting on. Here’s a quick tour of typical totals in popular sports, along with examples:

  • NFL (Football): NFL totals usually fall somewhere between the high 30s and mid 50s for most games. A matchup of two strong offensive teams might see a total around 52 or 54, whereas two defensive powerhouses (or a game in bad weather) might be down at 37–40. For example, an offensive showdown like a Chiefs vs. Chargers game could have a total of 55 (and indeed produce a 30-27 type shootout), while a matchup like a 2023 Patriots vs. Jets in heavy rain might be set around 36.5 and still go under in a 13-10 slog. Keep in mind key numbers for NFL totals – common combined scores like 41, 44, 37 tend to crop up often. (Those numbers correspond to common score combinations like 24-17, 27-14, 20-17, etc.) In fact, 41 is historically the most frequent NFL total (around 3.9% of games), with 37 and 44 right behind. So a total of 44 means the game is expected to be moderately high scoring, whereas 37 signals a likely defensive battle.
  • College Football: College football can be even more extreme. With so many teams and styles, you’ll see some totals soar into the 70s or even 80s for two fast-paced, offense-first teams, while a matchup of run-heavy teams might be in the 30s. For example, if Oklahoma faces Texas Tech, the total might be 75 because both offenses can light up the scoreboard. Meanwhile, when service academies like Army and Navy play, totals plummet – it’s not unusual to see an Army-Navy game with a total in the low 30s (or even lower). In fact, the Army–Navy rivalry famously went under the total 16 years in a row (2006–2021) due to their run-heavy, clock-draining offenses . In 2023, that game had an astoundingly low total of ~28.5 points (one of the lowest ever posted in college football) and it still hit the under in a 17-11 final! So college football totals can range from video-game high to historically low, all depending on the teams and style of play.
  • NBA (Basketball): NBA game totals typically range from around 210 to 240 points in today’s game. Two defensive, slow-tempo teams might produce a total in the low 200s (say 205–210), whereas two high-octane offensive teams that push the pace can be up around 240+. For instance, if the Golden State Warriors play the Brooklyn Nets and both are healthy and playing fast, you might see a total of 238.5, anticipating a 120-118 type of game. On the other hand, if two grind-it-out teams with strong defense meet, like a playoff game between defensive-minded squads, the total might be 200 or even under. (Not long ago, seeing a total under 200 was common; it’s rarer now with higher scoring trends, but it still happens for certain matchups or in the playoffs when pace slows down.) It’s all about pace and efficiency – an NBA team’s pace of play and offensive efficiency stats are big factors for bookmakers.
  • College Basketball: Totals in college hoops are generally lower than the NBA because halves are shorter and scoring is a bit lower-paced. You might see college totals anywhere from around 120 for two slow, defensive teams (think Virginia-style pack-line defense teams) up to 160+ for two run-and-gun squads (like an up-tempo Big 12 or WCC game). For example, if Duke plays North Carolina in a year both have strong offenses, the total might be 155. But if Virginia plays Wisconsin, you might see 118 as a total. Also, college games can be unpredictable with scoring droughts or overtime swings, which makes totals betting a fun challenge.
  • MLB (Baseball): Baseball totals are based on runs, and typical game totals range roughly from 7 to 10 runs. A game featuring two ace pitchers might be as low as 6.5 or 7 (expecting a pitchers’ duel, like 3-2 type games). Conversely, a game in a hitter-friendly park with mediocre pitchers could be 10 or 11 runs. For example, a July game at Coors Field (Colorado’s high-altitude park) with two average starters might have a total of 11.5, whereas a game at a pitcher-friendly park like San Francisco with top pitchers might be 7.0. Weather and wind play a role too – wind blowing out can bump totals up because it’s easier to hit home runs, while a stiff wind blowing in can knock totals down. Baseball also has the quirk of listed pitchers: if a starting pitcher is scratched, the total might be reposted because a different pitcher can change the expected runs significantly.
  • NHL (Hockey): Hockey totals are expressed in goals, and they’re usually around 5 to 6.5 goals. Common numbers are 5.5 or 6 for many games. A matchup with hot goalies or defensive-minded teams might be 5.0 (though 5 is a pretty low total in modern NHL), and an offensive matchup or one with shaky goaltending could be 6.5 or occasionally even 7. For instance, if the Toronto Maple Leafs (a high-scoring team) play the Edmonton Oilers (another offensive powerhouse) and both starting goalies are average, you might see 7 as the total. But if two top goalies face off, even if the teams have skill, the total might be 5.5. It’s worth noting that empty-net goals at the end can swing a hockey total, and overtime/shootouts count for totals, so a 2-2 game that goes to OT (4 total goals) could end 3-2 in OT or shootout (5 goals) and push a 5.0 or go over a 4.5 – a nail-biter for bettors.

As you can see, “over/under” can mean 5 goals or 55 points or 10 runs – it all depends on the sport. The key is understanding what a typical score is in that sport and what factors might make this particular game higher or lower scoring than average.

Derivative & Prop Totals: Team Totals, Halves, Quarters, and More

So far we’ve talked about the game total, meaning the combined score of both teams in the entire game. But sportsbooks offer many related over/under bets beyond just the full game total. These are often called derivatives or prop totals, and they allow you to bet on subsets of the game or specific team outcomes. Here are some common ones:

  • Team Totals: Instead of betting on the combined score, you can bet on how many points (or runs/goals) one specific team will score. The sportsbook will set a line for each team. For example, in an NFL game with a 48 point total, Team A’s team total might be 27.5 and Team B’s 20.5 (reflecting that Team A is favored and expected to score more). If you bet a team’s over, you need that single team to score more than that number. This is great when you have a strong read on one offense or defense – e.g. you think the Chiefs will light it up, but you’re not sure about the other team, you might take Chiefs Team Total Over 27.5. Team totals are popular in sports like football and soccer (betting a club’s over/under on goals). It’s essentially isolating one side’s performance.
  • First-Half and Second-Half Totals: You don’t have to bet the whole game; books often offer totals for each half (and even quarters/periods). A first-half total bet looks at just the first half score. For instance, if an NBA game total is 220, the first-half total might be around 110 (not always exactly half, but roughly). Similarly, an NFL game with a total of 50 might have a first-half total of ~24. Betting first halves can be useful if you expect a fast start or slow start specifically. Maybe two teams script aggressive offense early (good for first-half over), or maybe they tend to start slow and adjust (could take first-half under). There are also quarter totals in basketball and football (each quarter of play) and period totals in hockey (each 20-minute period). These allow very fine-grained bets – for example, you can bet 1st Quarter Over 10.5 points in an NFL game, or 2nd Period Under 1.5 goals in an NHL game. They’re shorter spans, so variance is high, but they can present opportunities if you know a team’s tendencies.
  • Over/Under Props (Stat Totals): Many proposition bets are essentially over/unders on specific stats or outcomes. These aren’t about the final score, but they work the same way. For example, player props often use totals: “LeBron James over/under 28.5 points” – you bet on whether he’ll score 29+ or 28 or fewer. Or a baseball prop might be “Over/Under 7.5 strikeouts by Max Scherzer.” There are team props too, like “Total team sacks Over/Under 4.5” in a football game. Even exotic props like “Total 3-pointers made by both teams Over/Under 25.5” in an NBA All-Star game, or “Total number of goals in the tournament” for a World Cup futures prop. Essentially, any time you see a number and can bet “over” or “under”, it’s a totals wager, just applied to something more specific than the final score. These prop totals are usually found in big games (Super Bowl has tons of them) or as daily player prop markets, and they can be softer lines if you do your research on specific matchups or player performance trends.

All these derivative totals work on the same principle as the game total: the sportsbook sets a line, and you pick over or under.

One thing to note is rules may vary for these – for example, some books might list a team total as void if the game doesn’t go the full time (like a baseball game that gets rain-shortened could void team totals if it didn’t reach a certain inning).

But generally, the bet is action as long as the period in question is played. These options give bettors flexibility: if you see an edge in a specific segment or team, you can zero in on that rather than the full game.

What Makes Totals Move? (Line Movement Explained)

Once sportsbooks set an initial total, the number can move up or down before (and even during) the game based on various factors. If you’ve ever watched a total open at, say, 47 and later see it at 49 or 45, that’s line movement in action. Understanding why totals move can help you anticipate changes or grab a good number before it’s gone. Here are the main drivers of total line movement:

  • Sharp Money vs. Public Money: One of the biggest factors is betting action – specifically WHO is betting. Public bettors (recreational bettors, the general betting public) tend to love betting overs (more on that later), and their action can nudge a total upward if a lot of casual money pours in on the over. However, sportsbooks know public betting patterns and won’t overreact to small bets. Sharp bettors (professional bettors or those with respected opinions) can move lines more dramatically. When sportsbooks take big bets from sharps on one side of the total, they will often adjust the number quickly to limit liability. For example, if the total is 45 and a known sharp syndicate unloads on the under, the book might drop the total to 44 or 43.5 within minutes. Sometimes you’ll see a total move against the public betting trend – like 80% of bets on the over, yet the total drops from 45 to 43. This is a classic case of reverse line movement, indicating sharp money is on the under despite the public leaning over. Sportsbooks respect sharp action more than raw ticket count. So a flood of small public bets might inch a total up half a point, but one or two large sharp bets can swing it multiple points.
  • Injuries and Lineup Changes (News): As mentioned earlier, if a key player’s status changes, the total will move. Imagine an NBA total set assuming a star player will play, and an hour before tip-off it’s announced he’s out – you might see the total drop several points immediately. Or a football game where the weather looked fine, but on game day the starting QB tweaks a hamstring in warm-ups and is out – the total could plummet because the backup QB might not score as much. Bettors who react quickly to news can beat the book to the punch, but these days books are fast to adjust. Always be aware of injury reports and late-breaking news if you’re betting close to game time; those can drastically alter a total.
  • Weather and Conditions: Weather is such a crucial factor for football (and to an extent baseball) totals that we have to mention it again in the context of line moves. If a forecast a few days out calls for mild weather but the day before the game it changes to heavy wind and rain, you can bet that under money will pour in and the total will drop. Wind is the number one weather factor for football totals – strong winds can cripple the passing and kicking game, leading to lower scores. We’ve seen games where a total opened around 50 in clear conditions, but then 30 mph winds were forecast and the total closed in the low 40s after bettors (especially sharps) hammered the under. A famous recent example was a Patriots-Bills game in Buffalo with extreme wind in 2021: the wind was so bad the Patriots threw only 3 passes all game and it ended 14-10, obliterating the under. The total had dropped several points once the weather report became clear. Snow or rain can also cause a drop, though moderate snow isn’t as predictive of an under as people think (sometimes snowy fields still see decent scoring, as footing can actually favor offenses at times). In baseball, if rain is likely to shorten a game or if there’s heavy air (less carry for the ball), totals might tick down. On the flip side, a change to better conditions can raise a total: e.g. if a football game gets moved from an outdoor stadium in a storm to an indoor venue (it has happened), the total will jump up due to the improved scoring environment.
  • Pace and Matchup Adjustments: Occasionally, as the matchup is analyzed more deeply, bettors might decide the total was off because of expected pace of play or strategic matchups. For instance, early in the week a college basketball total might be set without much fanfare, but as bettors dig in, they realize both teams like to run and the game could be a track meet – you might see that total creep up a few points as over bettors hit it. Or maybe two football teams are thought to be high-scoring, but further analysis shows when they last met, they played a ball-control game, or one team’s defense matches up well to slow the other. If sharps anticipate a slower game than the number implies, they’ll bet the under and the line will fall. These are more subtle moves, often a point at a time, driven by deeper analytical takes on the game that differ from the opener.
  • Betting Market Dynamics: Sometimes it’s just pure market demand. If an overwhelming majority of bettors (public and sharp combined) all see value on one side, the books will have to move the line to attract action on the other side. Totals can also move because of line shopping and arbitrage – if one sportsbook has 47 and another has 46, bettors might pound the over 46 and under 47 to try to hit a middle (win both if the game lands 47). This activity can cause books to adjust toward a consensus. And as game time nears, limits increase at sportsbooks, meaning bigger bets can come in, which often cause late “steam” moves – a sudden jump in the total an hour or less before game time, triggered by large pro action. If you ever see a total jump from, say, 47 to 49 thirty minutes before kickoff, that’s likely late steam hitting the market (often syndicates or last-minute information).

The key takeaway is that lines move for a reason. Paying attention to line movement on totals can give you clues.

If you see a total crashing down, ask why: Is there a weather issue? An injury? Sharp money? If it’s shooting up, is there new info or just everyone hammering the over?

Understanding these moves can help you make your bet at the optimal time (which brings us to strategies on timing and line shopping next).

Tips and Strategies for Betting Over/Under Totals

Betting totals isn’t just about picking over or under at random – there are strategies you can use to give yourself a better shot at winning. Here are some tips and best practices for over/under betting:

  • Shop for the Best Line: This is rule #1 in any kind of sports betting, but it’s especially true for totals. A half-point difference can turn a loss into a push or a push into a win. Always check multiple sportsbooks if you can. For example, you might find one book offering Over/Under 47 while another has 47.5 on the same game. If you want the over, you definitely prefer 47; if you want the under, 47.5 is your friend. Getting an extra half-point (or full point) on a total – especially around those key numbers like 37, 41, 44 in the NFL – is worth the effort. The sports betting marketplace is competitive; use that to your advantage. Even if the odds are slightly different (e.g. one book is over 47 -115, another is over 47.5 -105), think about what matters more: price vs. number. Often, having the better number is crucial on totals. Key numbers do matter: for instance, an NFL total of 45 vs 44.5 can be significant (games land on 45 fairly often like 24-21 or 28-17). So always try to get the best number available for your bet.
  • Time Your Bet (Early vs. Late): Deciding when to place your total bet can be as important as what you bet. If you expect the public to heavily bet one side, you might either bet early to get ahead of a move or wait it out to get a better number. A common scenario: The public loves overs, especially in primetime games or high-profile matchups. If you like the over in a game and you anticipate everyone else will too, consider betting it early (when lines open or early in the week) because the line might only go up from there (making it harder to win the later you wait). Conversely, if you like the under and you know Joe Public is drooling over the over, it might pay to wait closer to game time – you could get an extra point or two higher once all that public money pushes the total up. For example, if you think a Monday Night Football game is going to be a defensive struggle (you like under), but the matchup features popular explosive offenses, you know the average bettors will bet the over all day. The total might open 54 and by Monday evening it’s 56 after everyone bets the over. If you held off, now you can grab under 56 instead of 54 – a significant difference. On the flip side, if sharps are likely to pounce on a bad total number, they’ll do it early. Sometimes the best time to bet an over/under is the moment it opens, if your handicap strongly disagrees with the opener. Totals can move quickly if they’re off, so being ready to jump can get you a great number that’s gone within hours. Pay attention to opening lines and early moves each week.
  • Consider the Game Script: Before betting a total, imagine how you expect the game to unfold. This is sometimes called matchup analysis or envisioning the game script. Ask yourself: Will it be a fast or slow game? A defensive chess match or an offensive showcase? Factors to consider include:
  • Styles of play: Do the teams run or pass? Fast-break or half-court? A team that runs the ball 70% of the time will chew clock (lean under), whereas two pass-happy teams can create more plays and clock stoppages (lean over).
  • Coaching tendencies: Some coaches are aggressive (go for 4th downs, two-point conversions, trick plays – which can increase scoring opportunities), while others are conservative (settle for field goals, punt on 4th and short, etc. – which can keep scores lower). Also, if one coach knows his defense is outmatched, he might slow the game down deliberately (we saw coaches of big underdogs milk the play clock to shorten games and keep totals low). Conversely, a coach with a high-powered offense might keep his foot on the gas.
  • Potential mismatches: Does one team have a huge offensive edge? If so, they might score a lot – but also could get up big and then run out the clock in the second half, actually slowing the pace late (a common under scenario in blowouts). Or if both teams have great offenses but also weak defenses, it screams over – unless one offense jumps out so far ahead that the second half becomes one-sided and slower. Consider if the game is likely to stay competitive (often better for overs, as both teams keep attacking) or become a blowout (which can sometimes kill an over late if the leading team eases up).
  • In-game situations: Think about things like red zone efficiency (do the teams typically finish drives with TDs or settle for field goals?), turnover propensity (turnovers can either stop scoring drives or create instant scoring chances the other way), and special teams (a game with explosive kick returners might steal an extra touchdown, whereas teams with great punters could pin each other deep and force longer fields). Also, overtime is a sneaky factor – in a tied game late, an over can benefit from an overtime period (since totals count overtime points). If you think a game is likely to be close and around the number, overtime could push it over. (We’ve all seen an under bet get busted by overtime points – e.g. tied 20-20 going into OT, total was 41, and then it ends 23-20 = 43, over hits in OT). Obviously, you can’t bank on OT, but it’s part of the risk if you bet unders in evenly matched games.
    The better you can predict the game flow, the more confident you can be in whether the total is too high or too low. For example, you might analyze an upcoming college football game and determine: Team A’s strength (power run game) lines up with Team B’s weakness (run defense), so Team A likely will run successfully and control the clock; meanwhile Team B has a backup QB and will probably be conservative – that paints a picture of an under. Or in an NBA game, maybe both teams like to run and neither has a rim protector – you envision lots of fast-break points and easy buckets, suggesting the over. Craft a little narrative of how you see the game going; if that narrative’s total points differ significantly from the posted total, you might have a solid bet.
  • Watch for Reverse Line Movement and Late Steam: We touched on reverse line movement (RLM) earlier – that’s when the line moves opposite to the public betting percentages. This can be a tip-off that sharp money is on one side. If you’re seeing 75% of bets on the over but the total is dropping, it likely means smart bettors hammered the under. As a strategy, some bettors like to follow the sharp movement – basically, if they see clear RLM to the under, they might jump on under as well (or over if the opposite happens). It’s not a guaranteed success, but it’s aligning with the big money. Separately, late steam refers to sudden, significant line moves close to game time, usually from syndicates or inside info. If five minutes before tip-off a basketball total jumps from 221 to 224, some group likely got info (maybe a key player who was a game-time decision is going to play, or they just unloaded a big wager). If you’re live-monitoring lines, catching that move right as it starts could let you piggyback before it moves even more. But be cautious: jumping in after a steam move means you might get a worse number. Chasing steam can be like a game of musical chairs. A better approach is to be ahead of moves when possible – anticipate them by reading the situation (e.g. “If player X is announced out, I know sharps will hit the under, so I’ll bet it now before the news”).
  • Be Aware of “Key” Total Numbers: Just as there are key numbers in NFL point spreads (like 3 and 7), totals have key numbers – especially in football. As noted, common totals in NFL land on numbers like 41, 44, 51, etc. This means if you’re betting an NFL total, a shift from 47 to 47.5 isn’t as big as a shift from 47.5 to 48, for example, because 48 (think 27-21 or 30-18) happens a decent amount. In NFL, the most frequent combined scores historically are around 41, 43, 44, 37, 51 and so on. So, avoid crossing a key number the wrong way if you can. For instance, if you like an over and it’s at 43.5, you’d hate to wait and see it move to 44.5, because you just crossed 44 (a key number) and now a 27-17 game (44) that would have pushed you now loses. Similarly for an under bettor: getting under 51.5 instead of 50.5 is meaningful. This again ties into line shopping and timing – try to lock in at or around key numbers favorably. Some advanced bettors even buy a half-point (pay extra juice) to get on or off a key total number in NFL, though that’s debatable in value. The main point: treat certain total points as milestones in football betting.
  • Don’t Fall for the “Obvious” Over (or Under): Sportsbooks are very savvy. If a matchup looks like a sure-fire shootout to everyone, the total will be posted high accordingly. You might think, “These teams score a ton, the over can’t miss!” but remember the line accounts for that. In fact, if anything, value might lie the other way if the total is inflated. Same goes for an “obvious” under – like two great defenses meeting in bad weather, and the total is extremely low. Before blindly following the obvious, consider if the number has adjusted too far. For example, you might see an NFL total of 38 because of expected snow and two defensive teams. It feels natural to take the under in a game where it might be 13-10. But maybe the line has dropped from 42 to 38 already – much of the value is gone, and at 38 you’re near a bottom. One fluky defensive TD or special teams play could ruin an under that low. Always ask: “Is this line already baking in those factors?” If everyone knows a game will be a track meet, the odds will reflect it. Your job is to identify where the total might be wrong relative to perception, not just in absolute terms. Sometimes the best over bet is when the public is not expecting a shootout at all, but you have reason to believe one could break out (and the total is set low). And the best under bet might be when everyone’s hyped for a high score, but you see cracks that suggest a tighter game.
  • Mind the Public vs. Sharp Narrative: A common misconception (which we’ll discuss next) is “public always on over, sharps on under.” While there’s some truth that casual bettors prefer overs (it’s more fun to root for points), be careful assuming all overs = square (public) and all unders = sharp. There are times when sharp bettors hammer an over, especially if they think the market hasn’t caught up to a new offensive trend or a mismatch. For instance, when a team changes coaches to a faster-paced style, early season overs might be gold before books adjust. Or if a key defensive player is out and the total didn’t move enough, sharps might hit the over knowing points will come easier. As a strategy, try to be contrarian in the right spots, but contrarian doesn’t always mean take the under. It means go against widely held assumptions when you have good reason. Maybe everyone thinks a basketball game will be low-scoring because both teams have decent defenses, but you know they both play at a top-5 pace – that could be a sneaky over spot even if the public isn’t on it. The bottom line: use information and analysis to guide you, not just the over=public, under=sharp trope.
  • Track Line Moves and Results: Over time, keep notes on how totals move and how those games end. You might notice patterns. For example, perhaps you observe that late steam under moves in college football (total drops 3 points on game day) are hitting at a solid rate – that could inform you to trust those moves or even anticipate them. Or you might notice certain teams consistently go over or under the total due to play style quirks that the market hasn’t fully corrected for (some bettors specialize in one sport and get a feel for when totals are off). Use historical data to inform future bets. Many sites track team over/under records (e.g. “Team X is 11-5 to the over this season”) , which can hint at whether oddsmakers are mis-estimating them or if it’s just randomness. Just be careful: a trend like “8 of the last 10 games went over” could just mean the book will adjust and the value now might be under. Trends are useful but always ask why a trend is happening. If you can answer that, you’ll know if it’s likely to continue or regress.
  • Special Situations & Props: If you’re into derivative totals and props, strategy there can be very specific. For team totals, consider correlation with the game spread – e.g. if you like a big underdog + points, sometimes taking the favorite’s team total under can align (if the dog covers, maybe the favorite didn’t score as much as expected). For first-half totals, look at teams’ first-half scoring vs second-half. Some teams script great starts then slow down, others start slow and explode later. You might find an edge like first-half under but full-game over (expecting a late surge). For player props (like a player’s points or yards), if you think a game will be an extreme over or under, it can influence those props (lots of points usually means star players overs could hit; a defensive game might mean looking at unders on big names’ stats). Also, be mindful of garbage time: in a blowout, the full game total might go under, but a losing team’s QB could rack up passing yards over his prop in meaningless time. These nuances illustrate that context is everything.

That’s a lot of tips – you don’t need to use every one for every bet, but keeping these principles in mind will make you a more informed totals bettor. Totals can be very profitable if you’re diligent because casual bettors often overlook many of these factors.

Common Misconceptions About Over/Under Bets

Like any popular betting market, totals have their share of myths and misconceptions. Let’s clear up a few:

  • “The Public Always Bets the Over (and the Under is the Sharp Side).” It’s true that casual bettors lean toward overs – it’s just more fun to root for points and big plays, and psychologically people prefer to bet on things happening rather than not happening. Sportsbooks know this and sometimes shade lines upward a bit, meaning the number might be a point or so higher than a pure model would make it, expecting public over money. This leads many to assume taking the under is automatically the “smart” or “sharp” play. However, be careful. Unders aren’t always the right side – and blindly betting under because you think it’s contrarian can backfire. Yes, many professional bettors do like certain unders (especially if a total is inflated or conditions favor it), but sharps will just as soon pound an over if it’s mispriced low. The key is value. Don’t take an under (or over) just because you think “everyone” is on the other side; take it because your analysis says the total is off. Sometimes the public is actually right about a game going over! The book might post a high number, and it still isn’t high enough. In short, while the sentiment behind this myth has some basis – you generally won’t find value chasing the same over everyone and their brother is on – you should evaluate each total on its own merits. If you find yourself on the same side as the public, that’s okay as long as you have a good reason. And if you’re on the under just to be a contrarian, double-check that the line isn’t already accounting for everything.
  • “High Totals Go Under and Low Totals Go Over.” This is a saying some bettors throw around, implying that when a total is extremely high, you should go under because it’s been inflated, and when it’s extremely low, go over because it’s too low. There are cases where a super-high total (say an NBA All-Star Game total of 300, or a college football total of 82) might still go over because the matchup genuinely produces that much scoring. And some low totals (like a hockey total of 5 or a football total of 35) can still go under if conditions warrant. Rather than using a blanket rule, consider why the total is high or low. Often a very high total means two explosive offenses and maybe suspect defenses – a combination ripe for overs. It might also mean the sportsbook knows public will bet over regardless, but don’t assume they’ve overshot; sometimes they haven’t shot high enough (games can and do eclipse even big numbers). Conversely, a very low total means points are expected to be scarce – perhaps two elite defenses or weak offenses. Betting the over just because “it can’t be that low” isn’t wise unless you have a tangible angle. Remember, oddsmakers are good at what they do. If something looks outlandishly high or low, there’s a reason. Use your own judgment on if that reason is fully justified.
  •  “If a Total Moves a Lot, It’s Free Money.” You might see a total move several points (say from 50 down to 45) and think “Wow, everyone must know it’s going under, I’ll jump on under 45.” But hold on – once a total has moved significantly, the value on that side might be gone (or even now value lies the other way). The market often over-adjusts after big moves. For instance, early sharp action might have rightly bet under 50, under 49, under 48… but under 45 might be iffy. If you missed the good numbers, be cautious about following the steam at a worse price. Sometimes it’s better to pass a bet if you’re late to the party. Or if you have a contrarian streak and solid reasoning, you might go against a big move (e.g. everyone hammered under and now it’s too low, so you go over at the deflated line – this is advanced and not for the faint of heart, but it can be profitable in certain spots). The misconception is that a line move = guaranteed outcome. Not at all – lines move to balance action and adjust to info, but they’re still just an estimate. Plenty of games sail over after the total dropped (because maybe it dropped too far), or stay under after the total rose (because it rose too much). Use line moves as information, not gospel.
  • “Overtime will save my over / Overtime can’t hurt my under if it’s low scoring.” We touched on overtime, but to reiterate: overtime counts for totals in virtually all standard bets. That means an under can be winning comfortably in regulation and still lose in OT (especially in basketball or football where overtime adds significant points). Never assume an under is safe until the final whistle – crazy things happen, like multiple overtimes in college basketball turning a sure under into a wild over. On the flip side, don’t rely on overtime to bail out a bad over bet. It’s a nice backdoor if it happens, but it’s rare enough that you shouldn’t count on it. Some bettors will say “I only bet over in basketball because you have OT as a bonus chance” – that’s a flawed strategy if the number isn’t good. Yes, overtime is a small extra edge for overs (because an under bet can never win because of overtime, only lose, whereas an over can win because of overtime), but it’s typically not worth skewing your decision heavily. It’s just something to be aware of: if you bet an under in a game likely to be close at the end, you’re implicitly taking on OT risk. And if you bet an over in a game that might be a blowout, note that overtime is probably off the table (since blowouts don’t go to OT). Factor it in, but don’t obsess over it.
  • “I lost three overs in a row, so the next one is due to hit (gambler’s fallacy).” It’s worth mentioning general betting psychology: each game’s total is independent. Just because a bunch of games went under yesterday doesn’t mean today’s will go over to “even it out.” The sportsbooks aren’t running a quota system of overs vs. unders. Over the very long run, things might approach a balance (some sports historically hit under ~50-52% depending on how lines are shaded), but you should never make a bet thinking it’s “due.” Handicap each matchup on its own. Streaks of overs or unders happen. Sometimes weather across the league causes a bunch of unders in a week. Sometimes a new rule change (like the NFL moving extra points back in 2015 or the NBA’s pace increasing in recent years) can cause a run of overs or unders until books adjust. Always look for the reason behind trends rather than assuming reversion to the mean in the short term.

In summary, be wary of simplistic sayings. Totals betting, like all betting, is nuanced. There’s rarely an always/never rule that holds true. Staying analytical and avoiding these mental traps will serve you well.

Final Thoughts: Becoming a Savvy Totals Bettor

Over/under betting is a fantastic way to engage with sports because it turns the game into a kind of story – will it be an offensive showcase or a defensive duel? As we’ve seen, the total is influenced by everything from team strategy and player talent to weather forecasts and betting market psychology.

To recap some key points:

  • An over/under bet is simply wagering on the combined score of both teams. It’s you vs. the line, predicting over (more points than the line) or under (fewer points).
  • Sportsbooks set totals using data and expertise, but those numbers move with action and information. Keep an eye on why a total is moving – it can tell you a lot.
  • Every sport has its own scoring range and quirks: a 7-run baseball total is low; a 7-goal hockey total is high. Context is everything. Always consider the sport and situation.
  • There are many ways to bet totals beyond just the full game. Team totals, halves, quarters, and props let you slice and dice the game into smaller bets if you see an edge in one area.
  • Successful totals betting often means thinking like a coach or analyst: What kind of game should we expect? Fast, slow, high risk, conservative? Use stats like pace, efficiency, and matchups to inform your bets.
  • Line shopping and timing can significantly improve your winning chances. Grabbing a 0.5 point better line or betting before a key injury news hits can be the difference between a win and a loss.
  • Don’t be afraid to be contrarian if the situation calls for it. Some of the best under bets are when everyone is obsessed with the over (and vice versa). But have a real reason – not contrarian for contrarian’s sake, but because you have legitimate info or analysis that the crowd is overlooking.
  • Manage those expectations and emotions: there will be bad beats (like an unnecessary late touchdown ruining an under, or a team missing a field goal that would’ve pushed an over). That’s part of totals betting. It’s gut-wrenching at times, but also thrilling. Staying level-headed and focusing on making good bets (not just winning every bet) is how you succeed long term.

In the end, betting totals combines statistical know-how with a bit of gut feel for the game. With the tips from this guide, you should be well on your way to spotting solid over/under opportunities. Whether you’re cheering for a flurry of points or praying for every clock to run out, always remember to have fun and bet responsibly.

Good luck, and may all your overs be shootouts and your unders be snoozers!

Get Jimmy's picks for free!

You'll get free picks via email, plus access to exclusive discounts!

We won't spam you - ever. No obligation. You can unsubscribe at any time.

×

Subscribe to Jimmy Boyd's Free Picks

The best free picks delivered to your email every single day!