The NFL is a quarterback driven league. No player’s performance has a bigger impact on whether they make it to the Super Bowl or not. For the most part, elite signal callers tend to run the show. However, we have seen multiple game-managers find their way into the big game.
The big difference between those game-managers and the elite quarterbacks, is the ability to get back to the big game. There have been just 20 quarterbacks to make multiple Super Bowl appearances. Of those 20, only 12 have made at least 3 trips.
NFL Signal Callers Who Have Made More Than One Super Bowl Appearance
The numbers get even smaller when you start looking at quarterbacks that have made 4 or more starts. In fact, just 6 players can claim that accomplishment.
At the top of the list is Tom Brady, who made his 10th appearance in Super Bowl 55. The previous record was held by John Elway with 5. They are the only two QBs with more than 4 starts in the Super Bowl.
While getting to the Super Bowl is quite an accomplishment, the thing that matters above all is wins. The most Super Bowl wins by a single quarterback is 6. An honor that belongs to none other than Tom Brady, who simply is re-writing the record books.
Joe Montana (49ers) and Terry Bradshaw (Steelers) are tied for 2nd on the list with 4. The impressive thing with Montana and Bradshaw is both went a perfect 4-0 in the big game.
Of the quarterbacks who have made multiple appearances, 14 of the 21 did so in back-to-back trips. The first to do so was Bart Star back in Super Bowl I & II. A feat Brady has accomplished twice in his career. The most recent was Patrick Mahomes, who piloted the Kansas City Chiefs to the big game in both the 2019 and 2020 NFL seasons.
The quarterback who holds the record for most consecutive trips to the Super Bowl is Jim Kelly. He led the Buffalo Bills to four straight appearances from 1991-94. Unfortunately for Kelly and the Bills, they lost all four games.
What about quarterbacks who have taken multiple teams to a Super Bowl? It’s only happened four times. The most recent was again Tom Brady. He guided both the Patriots and Buccaneers to two different Super Bowls.
The first to do so was Craig Morton. He quarterbacked the Cowboys in Super Bowl V, then later led the Broncos in Super Bowl XII.
The other quarterback in this group is Kurt Warner. He made two appearances with the Rams before ending his career by taking the Cardinals to SB XLIII.
Complete List of Quarterbacks With Multiple Super Bowl Starts
|Quarterback||Starts||Record||Team(s)||Year Super Bowl Played|
|Tom Brady||10||6-3*||New England Patriots (9), Tampa Bay Buccaneers (1)||2002, 2004, 2005, 2008, 2012, 2015, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2021|
|John Elway||5||2-3||Denver Broncos||1987, 1988, 1989, 1998, 1999|
|Terry Bradshaw||4||4-0||Pittsburgh Steelers||1975, 1976, 1979, 1980|
|Joe Montana||4||4-0||San Francisco 49ers||1982, 1985, 1989, 1990|
|Roger Staubach||4||2-2||Dallas Cowboys||1972, 1976, 1978, 1979|
|Jim Kelly||4||0-4||Buffalo Bills||1991, 1992, 1993, 1994|
|Troy Aikman||3||3-0||Dallas Cowboys||1993, 1994, 1996|
|Bob Greise||3||2-1||Miami Dolphins||1972, 1973, 1974|
|Ben Roethlisberger||3||2-1||Pittsburgh Steelers||2006, 2009, 2011|
|Kurt Warner||3||1-2||St. Louis Rams (2), Arizona Cardinals||2000, 2002, 2009|
|Fran Tarkenton||3||0-3||Minnesota Vikings||1974, 1975, 1977|
|Peyton Manning||4||1-2||Indianapolis Colts (2), Denver Broncos (2)||2007, 2010, 2014, 2016|
|Bart Starr||2||2-0||Green Bay Packers||1967, 1968|
|Jim Plunkett||2||2-0||Oakland/L.A. Raiders||1981, 1984|
|Eli Manning||2||2-0||New York Giants||2008, 2012|
|Len Dawson||2||1-1||Kansas City Chiefs||1967, 1970|
|Joe Theismann||2||1-1||Washington Redskins||1983, 1984|
|Brett Favre||2||1-1||Green Bay Packers||1997, 1998|
|Craig Morton||2||0-2||Dallas Cowboys, Denver Broncos||1971, 1978|
|Russell Wilson||2||1-1||Seattle Seahawks||2014, 2015|
|Patrick Mahomes||2||1-0*||Kansas City Chiefs||2020, 2021|