Look at How High-Seeded Mid-Majors Perform in the NCAA Tournament

• Jump to:
• First Round
• Second Round
• Sweet 16
• Elite Eight
• Final Four
• Championship

The 2026 NCAA Tournament field had just one mid-major team with a high seed (1-4): Gonzaga out of the West Coast Conference (WCC), seeded No. 3. The 2024 and 2025 fields had none, the first time since 1985 that two straight tournaments went without one.

It was the 13th time since 2004 that the Bulldogs were seeded 1-4, the most of any school on these lists. Gonzaga beat No. 14 Kennesaw State 73-64 but lost 74-68 to No. 11 Texas in the second round. As a No. 1 seed the Bulldogs reached the championship game twice, falling to North Carolina 71-65 in 2017 and to Baylor 86-70 in 2021. From 2026-27 Gonzaga plays in the rebuilt Pac-12, which we count as a mid-major league, so a high seed in the 76-team 2027 field would add to its rows here.

Houston was the other regular in recent years out of the American Athletic, a No. 3 seed in 2019, a No. 2 in 2021 (when it reached the Final Four) and a No. 1 in 2023. It moved to the Big 12 in 2023-24, so its later seeds aren’t counted here.

Let’s take a look: how have these kinds of teams fared in the past?  Do they make good sleeper teams?  Are they worth a look with the NCAA tournament odds as teams that show some value?

I went back over every tournament since 1985. The focus is on 1-4 seeds from non-power conferences. Some teams that used to be considered mid-majors have since joined power conferences. We use the conference the team was in for the season listed. Here are the results.

Look at How High-Seeded Mid-Majors Perform in March Madness

Round of 64

Record: 74-5 (93.67%)

Mid-major teams seeded 1-4 are excellent when it comes to the first round of the tournament. These are teams that had a special season to gain the recognition of the selection committee.

They also play low-seeded teams that just made the tournament or received an automatic bid.

Record: 83-5 (94.32%), through 2026

Round of 32

Record: 43-31 (58.11%)

Once we get to the second official round of the tournament, things start to come apart. These teams still have a winning record, but it pales in comparison to the previous round.

For many of these teams getting past the first round might be a relief. Nobody wants to be that mid-major team that loses as a top seed in the first round. Once that pressure is off about 40% of those teams falter (33 of 83 since 1985).

Record: 50-33 (60.24%), through 2026

Sweet 16

Record: 23-20 (53.49%)

I expected to see a bigger drop-off than this in the Sweet 16. Mid-major teams who make it this far into the tournament must be the real-deal. They play much better opponents at this point.

Record: 27-23 (54.00%), through 2026

Elite Eight

Record: 12-11 (52.17%)

Again, I was a little bit surprised at how well mid-major teams performed at this level. Opponents here are usually 1 and 2 seeds. It is no small feat for them to win as much as they lose.

Record: 14-13 (51.85%), through 2026

Final Four

Record: 5-7 (41.67%)

The buck stops here. Only 6 of the 14 mid-major teams that have gone to the Final Four have made it to the championship game.

The only teams that have won in this situation are: Gonzaga (2017 and 2021), Memphis (2008, since vacated), Utah (1998), UNLV (1990) and Louisville (1986). These aren’t teams from power conferences, but they aren’t exactly pushovers either.

Record: 6-8 (42.86%), through 2026

Championship Game

Record: 2-3 (40%)

Louisville (1986) and UNLV (1990) are still the only mid-major teams to win a National Championship. Gonzaga lost the 2017 and 2021 title games.

Record: 2-4 (33.33%), through 2026

Conclusion

Mid-major teams perform well in the first round of the tournament. After the first round, it is a coin flip until the Final Four. Once these teams reach this level they tend to collapse.

More Coverage to Help You Win:

• Winning NCAA Bracket Tips
• Advanced Theory on Winning Bracket Pools

Get Jimmy's picks for free!

You'll get free picks via email, plus access to exclusive discounts!

<<

Sign Up

We won't spam you - ever. No obligation. You can unsubscribe at any time.